Between excessive centralization and hesitant decentralization

Prof. Rachelle Alterman, Einat Gavrieli

Cite As:
Alterman Rachelle, Gavrieli Einat. Between excessive centralization and hesitant decentralization Haifa Israel: Samuel Neaman Institute, 2008. https://neaman.org.il/EN/Between-excessive-centralization-and-hesitant-decentralization

Download files:

6-264.pdf(1249KB)

Amendment #43 to the Israel Planning and Building Law of 1995 was the most important step so far to devolve planning powers to the local planning commissions. The powers devolved, however, were minimal - the authority to approve a set category of amendments to local plans which contain only minor change to the existing plans. Even after this amendment, Israel's is among the most centralized planning systems. The most important of these is the power to approve plans. Even though the Amendment allows for only a modest degree of decentralization, it constitutes a turning point and a precedent and is already having far reaching implications for planning regulations and the quality of planning. In 2007 another small step was taken toward further decentralization of powers to the local level, but its implementation is gradual and will take many years. The lessons of the 1995 amendment are therefore crucial in anticipating the current move towards more decentralization.

The aim of this research is to look back and evaluate the manner and degree of implementation of Amendment #43. We examined the processes of decentralization in other countries. In Israel, we reviewed the legal and public policy background for enactment of Amendment #43 and evaluate its influence through an opinion survey.

The conclusions indicate that the decentralization process which began with Amendment #43 is only the beginning and there is no turning back. However to continue the process, the local authorities must be given the appropriate tools. The process of devolving powers to the local authorities must be accompanied by an increase in the number of planning positions on the local level, and appropriate budgets. Only then will decentralization be viable action rather than a hesitant set of insufficient steps.

Publications that might interest you

Reforming the legislative process in the Knesset: "House of Cards" or House of Legislature?

Manuel Trajtenberg , Itamar Popliker

National land ownership and housing prices in Israel

Rachelle Alterman , Ron Kenett , Eyal Salinger

Towards a reform of the tax system

Manuel Trajtenberg , Itamar Popliker

“Common Ground”: Agreed Road Map for Long-Term National Paradigms

Eitan Adres , Reuven Gal , Zehev Tadmor , Irad Yavneh

Focused Repatriation. The Demography and the Social Processes in the Jewish Communities in the World

Ilia Zatcovetsky , Ayelet Raveh , Daphne Getz

Arab minority participation in collective action for provision of public goods in the general Israeli society.

Eitan Adres

Survey Security Personal in the Mixed Cities 2020

Ali Nohad , Ruth Lewin-Chen , Ola Najami Yousef

Violence, Crime, and Policing in Arab Society in The Age of Covid

Ali Nohad , Ola Najami Yousef , Yonatan Arie

The Global Economic Impact of the Russia-Ukraine War

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

From Geo/Bio-Politics to G2G Agreements and Public–Private Partnership: the Unique Role of the Israeli Eco-System in Ethiopia

Shelly Gottfried , Amir Sabhat , Eleonora Poli , Ayelet Raveh , Ilia Zatcovetsky , Nebiyou Yirga

"Post-Truth" Phenomena: Definitions, Consequences and Solutions

Shakked Dabran-Zivan , Ayelet Baram-Tsabari

The IDF Conscription Model: Alternatives and novelties. Summary of a Round Table in Ben-Gurion's Spirit.

Reuven Gal , Shlomo Maital

The Development of the Israeli Research Universities

Uri Kirsch

Research Standing of Israeli Universities by Quantitative Indicators

Uri Kirsch

Excellence Evaluations of the Universities in Israel - Approaches, Issues and Achievments

Uri Kirsch

Ultra-Orthodox (‘Haredi’) Jews in Israel’s Society: A 2014 Status Report.

Reuven Gal

Adaptation to climate change in the local authorities

Ofira Ayalon , Haim Kutiel , Nurit Kliot , Manfred Green , Marcelo Sterenberg , Tammy Trop , Tzipi Eshet , Idan Liebes

Tax Benefits for R&D in Israel

Dan Peled , Benjamin Bental , Avi Sasi , Ilia Zatcovetsky

Survey and Database on Israel’s Scientific foreign Relations on a national and institutional level

Daphne Getz , Bahina Eidelman , Oshrat Katz Shacham , Ella Barzani , Golan Tamir , Eliezer Shein

Towards evidence based policy in science communication in Israel

Yael Barel , Ayelet Baram-Tsabari , Ran Peleg , Rony Armon , Ayelet Raveh

The Higher Education System in Israel - Issues, characteristics and unique Aspects

Uri Kirsch

Integration of electric and hybrid vehicles in Israel's transportation system – Phase B: economic analysis and life cycle assessment

Ofira Ayalon , Idan Liebes , Gadi Rosental , Dana Gabay

Integration of electric and hybrid vehicles in Israel's transportation system – Phase A: literature review

Ofira Ayalon , Yaara Grinberg , Idan Liebes , Gadi Rosental , Dana Gabay

Hazardous Household Chemicals and Hazardous Waste: Policy and Procedures Recommendations For Implementation in Israel

Debby Mir , Ofira Ayalon , Yaara Grinberg

Major Plan for Higher Education - Planning Versus Performance

Amnon Pazy

Interim Report of the Investigatory Team on the State of the Chemical Industry in Israel at the Beginning of the 21st Century

Gilead Fortuna , Yoram Avnimelech , Daphne Getz , Reuven Wachs , Ephraim Kehat , Zehev Tadmor

Science and Technology in the Israeli Consciousness

Eppie Yaar

The Jewish People Today: Between Necessity and Freedom

Aviezer Ravitzky

Comments on National Governance

Shlomo Avineri

The Necessity of Strategic Thinking: A Constitutive Vision for Israel and its Implications

Ruth Gavizon

Modern Jewish Identities and the State of Israel

Moshe Halbertal

A secular, liberal, modern vision of Israel

Zehev Tadmor

Reclaiming the Dead Sea, Alternatives for Action

Yoram Avnimelech , Yifaat Baron , Gadi Rosental , Machum Yehoshua , Giora Shacham

The Neaman Document -A study on Israeli Public Diplomacy; A Joint Project of the S. Neaman Institute, Technion And the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Israel.

Dov Shinar , Roei Davidson , Dalia Liran-Alper , Lea Mandelzis , Arye Naor , Anat First , Naama Maoz , Haim Hagay , Sagit Yakubovich , Moshe Elad , Meir Shlomo

India-Israel Collaborative Business Innovation: An examination of its potential and forces that shape it

Gilead Fortuna , Gad Ariav , Liron Nadav , Naftali Moser

Water for nature and rivers restoration – Summary and recommendations of the 3rd Water Forum

Eran Friedler , Miki Zaide , Abraham Shaviv , Yael Gilboa

Technion's Contribution to the Israeli Economy through its Graduates

Amnon Frenkel , Shlomo Maital

Towards Mapping National Innovation Ecosystem: Israel's Innovation ecosystem

Amnon Frenkel , Shlomo Maital , Eran Leck , Daphne Getz , Vered Gilad

Trust in the institutions and pride in Israel's achievements in the first decade of 2000

Eppie Yaar , Yasmin Alkalai

R&D outputs in Israel: Inventive Characteristics of Local and Foreign Activity in the Israel Patent Authority

Eran Leck , Daphne Getz , Ilia Zatcovetsky

The Economic Impact of the Abraham Accords After One Year: Passions vs. Interests

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

Past initiatives to strengthen the Israeli society: Lessons from the Past

Ron Kenett , Reuven Gal , Eitan Adres , Hagit Glickman , Ali Nohad , chezki Farkash

Energy Forum 54: Electrical Energy Storage

Gershon Grossman , Ayelet Raveh

Democracy as a Critical Infrastructure during a State of Emergency

Dina Zilber , Eli Salzberger , Yael Cohen-Rimer , Reuven Katz , Barak Medina , Mordechai Kremnitzer , Michael Birnhack , Rinat Klein

North Wind: Local Patriotism and National Crisis

Meirav Aharon Gutman , Ron Kenett , Yaron Yavelberg , Golan Tamir , Gil Rabivo

Israel in 2030, Liberal Democracy, Populistic or Autocracy? ‘Round Table’ Discussion

Eitan Adres , Reuven Gal , Eli Salzberger , Shlomo Maital , Ido Erev , Oshrat Katz Shacham

Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting and Registration System in Israel: Summary of Reports for 2014

Ofira Ayalon , Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Idan Liebes , Maayan Zerbib Tsion

Guidelines for Creating Educational Continuity During Prolonged Crisis Situations: Insights from the ' Education during crisis' Forum

Orit Hazzan , Tsipy Buchnik , Anat Even-Zahav

Assessment of greenhouse gas emissions intensity from electricity generation in Israel

Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Idan Liebes , Ofira Ayalon

Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting and Registration System in Israel: Summary of Reports for 2013

Ofira Ayalon , Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Tal Goldrath , Idan Liebes

Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting and Registration System in Israel: Summary of Reports for 2012

Ofira Ayalon , Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Tal Goldrath , Efrat Kerem

Assessment of the economic damage of the fuel leak at the junction Be'er Ora 12.03.14 - Economic opinion

Ofira Ayalon , Tzipi Eshet

Report PRIME ENIP Project Indices Data Scienc Technology Israel

Daphne Getz , Marian Shumaf - Tehawkho , Mansour Hani , Orly Nathan

Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting and Registration System in Israel: Summary of Reports for 2011

Ofira Ayalon , Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Tal Goldrath , Yaara Grinberg

Violence, Crime and Policing in Arab Towns

Ali Nohad , Ruth Lewin-Chen

Integration of electric and hybrid vehicles in Israel's transportation system

Ofira Ayalon , Yaara Grinberg , Idan Liebes , Gadi Rosental , Dana Gabay

National Environmental Priorities of Israel, Position Paper IV, Vol. 2: The Energy Market in Israel

Yoram Avnimelech , Ofira Ayalon

National Environmental Priorities of Israel, Position Paper IV, Vol. 3: Environmental Management

Yoram Avnimelech , Ofira Ayalon

What is happening inside the Haredi Home - Review of several aspects concerning the every day life of Ultra Orthodox Jews in Israel

Reuven Gal

National Priorities for the Environment in Israel - Position Paper III

Yoram Avnimelech , Ofira Ayalon

Between excessive centralization and hesitant decentralization

Rachelle Alterman , Einat Gavrieli

Mapping Research and Innovation in the State of Israel

Eran Leck , Guillermo A. Lemarchand , April Tash

National Priorities for the Environment in Israel - Position Paper II

Yoram Avnimelech

To unravel the "Gordian Knot" 2.0: Tackling congestion via road pricing and shared rides

Manuel Trajtenberg , Hadar Zer Aviv

Instruments for Open Space Preservation: What Can Israel learn from other countries?

Rachelle Alterman , Iris Hann

National Priorities for the Environment in Israel - Position Paper I

Yoram Avnimelech

Towards a New Fiscal Policy for Israel: Balancing Budgetary Responsibility and Societal Needs

Manuel Trajtenberg , Itamar Popliker

Towards a New Fiscal Policy for Israel: Balancing Budgetary Responsibility and Societal Needs

Manuel Trajtenberg , Itamar Popliker

Save lives, save jobs

Shlomo Maital

Characterization of knowledge transfer of Israeli universities based on indices of commercialization and technology transfer

Arnon Bentur , Avigdor Zonnenshain , Rafi Nave , Ella Barzani , Ilia Zatcovetsky

The Current Energy Situation in Israel as a Departure Point for Future Planning

Amnon Enav

High tech nation and market driven economy

Zehev Tadmor

Eretz Israel from Inside and Out: Reflections

ארץ ישראל מבפנים ומבחוץ

Samuel neaman

The Health System at a Roadcross

Manuel Trajtenberg

Protective layers in the war on Corona: A realistic model for handling pandemics

Nicky Kons , Ron Kenett

A Comparative Analysis of Academic Structure in the Universities and Institutions for Higher Education in Israel

Eli Israeli

Technology innovation process: Does Israel have competitive advantage in kmowledge-based products?

Hariolf Grupp , Amnon Frenkel , Shlomo Maital

A Technometric Analysis of Comparative Advantage in Selected High-Technology Industries in Israel, Final Report, Vol. I

Shlomo Maital , Hariolf Grupp , Amnon Frenkel , Knut Koschatzky

A Technometric Analysis of Comparative Advantage in Selected High-Technology Industries in Israel, Final Report, Vol. II

Shlomo Maital , Hariolf Grupp , Amnon Frenkel , Knut Koschatzky

Migration To and From Development Towns in Israel

Tobi Alfandari , Daniel Shefer

Proceedings of the Second International Workshop on Civilian Space Applications

Daniel Weihs

The Program for Neighborhood Renewal - The Great Experiment and its Conclusions

Rachelle Alterman , Arza Churchman

The Diagnostics Industry in Israel, Evaluating the Technological Level Using the Technometric System

Amnon Frenkel , Shlomo Maital

The Plastics Industry in Israel - Current Economic Status and Future Alternate Economic Outlook

David Frenkel , Shmuel Kenig

Absorption of Soviet Immigrants at the Technion

David Cohen

Plastic Materials: Markets and Technology by Global Region

Ramon Joshef Albalak , Shmuel Kenig

A Survey on the Penetration of Advanced Production Systems and Factory Automation into the Israeli Industry

Amos Drori , Nahum Finger , Boaz Golany , Ehud Lenz , Kenneth Preiss , Yaakov Rubinovitz , Moshe Shoham , Zeev Bonen

Neighborhood Renewal in Israel - Evaluation and Results

Naomi Carmon

Civilian Space Applications, Proceedings of the Workshop - Technion

Daniel Weihs , David Cohen

Supercomputers In Israel - Feasibility and Alternatives

G. Shaviv , M. Wolfshtein

National land ownership and housing prices in Israel

Rachelle Alterman , Ron Kenett , Eyal Salinger

Adaptation to climate change in the local authorities

Ofira Ayalon , Haim Kutiel , Nurit Kliot , Manfred Green , Marcelo Sterenberg , Tammy Trop , Tzipi Eshet , Idan Liebes

Towards Establishment of Environmental Committees in the Local Councils

Ofira Ayalon , Yael Atar Peled

A retrospective on the national policy for municipal solid waste management in Israel 2007-2022

Ofira Ayalon , Shira Daskal

The waste management crisis – A national project. Summary and recommendations The waste forum of Samuel Neaman Institute

Ofira Ayalon , Debby Kaufman , Naama Shapira , Baruch Weber

Between excessive centralization and hesitant decentralization

Rachelle Alterman , Einat Gavrieli

Between technology development and public transparency: creating tools for public discussion on business ventures and technological alternatives for treating solid waste

Ofira Ayalon , Yael Atar Peled , Yifaat Baron , Noam Gressel , Limor Spektorovsky

Feasibility of Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) waste treatment facilities in Israel

Ofira Ayalon , Efrat Elimelech , Maayan Zerbib Tsion

Economy and Society Adjustments to the Post-Corona Era: Recommendations

Gilead Fortuna , Avigdor Zonnenshain , Eitan Adres , Giora Shalgi , Yuval Neev , Rafi Nave , Ron Kenett , Tamar Dayan , Ofira Ayalon , Naama Shapira , Carmit Padan , Arnon Bentur , Shai Linn , Eli Eisenberg , Yossi Ben Dov