Fixing military conscription by adding new mistakes? Critical comments on “Equal for All” guideline.

Dr. Asaf Malhi, Prof. Stuart Cohen , Dr. Reuven Gal

Cite As:
Malhi Asaf, Cohen Stuart, Gal Reuven. Fixing military conscription by adding new mistakes? Critical comments on “Equal for All” guideline. Haifa Israel: Samuel Neaman Institute, 2021. https://neaman.org.il/EN/Recruitment-and-Equal-Service-for-All

Download files:

Fixing military conscription by adding new mistakes? Critical comments on “Equal for All” guideline.(2663KB)

The report is a critical review on the content of an official “Guideline” submitted by the ‘Pnima’ movement in early 2020, entitled "Recruitment and Equal Service for All."

At the heart of the outline is the proposal that all sectors of Israeli society, including the Arab and ultra-Orthodox ones, will be recruited at age 18, to either military or civilian service.

The Guideline was adopted by the Blue and White Party and presented by the Secretary of Defense as the basis for the future Conscription Law.

Aside from the positive intention behind this initiative, the proposed Guideline is not devoid of severe errors and failures.

The purpose of this paper is to expose these failures and to present facts and considerations that cast doubt on the implementation of the proposed plan.

Publications that might interest you

Review of the Impact of Natural Gas Based Transportation Fuels on Air Quality

Ofira Ayalon , Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Naama Shapira

Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting and Registration System in Israel: Summary of Reports for 2019

Ofira Ayalon , Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Naama Shapira

The Governmental Initiative to Develop the Biomed Sector in Singapore – A Case Study

Daphne Getz , Avida Shoham , Eliezer Shein , Ella Barzani

Academia in the pandemia period

Arnon Bentur , Avigdor Zonnenshain

Fixing military conscription by adding new mistakes? Critical comments on “Equal for All” guideline.

Asaf Malhi , Stuart Cohen , Reuven Gal

The world of engineering and engineers

Baruch Karp , Avigdor Zonnenshain , Arnon Bentur

Creative Ideation: A Review of the Literature

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

Technological forecasting for scientific and technological human resources- final report 2020

Daphne Getz , Tsipy Buchnik , Vered Gilad , Ella Barzani , Ayelet Raveh

Energy Forum 49: Integrating hydrogen into the Israeli energy sector

Gershon Grossman , Naama Shapira

The Corona Crisis as a Growth Engine for the North of Israel

Osnat Akirav , Gilead Fortuna , Avigdor Zonnenshain

Recommendations, Policies and Goals for the state of Israel - Leaders’ Summit on Climate Change Earth Day April 22nd -23rd 2021

Adi Wolfson , Yoni Sappir , Ofira Ayalon

Statistical analysis of Corona data: A Roundtable

Ron Kenett , David Steinberg , Edna Schechtman , Reuven Gal

Focused Repatriation. The Demography and the Social Processes in the Jewish Communities in the World

Ilia Zatcovetsky , Ayelet Raveh , Daphne Getz

Arab minority participation in collective action for provision of public goods in the general Israeli society.

Eitan Adres

Periphery-Academy relations: past, present and future

Carmit Padan

‘Tal’s Law’ – Background, Challenges and Optional Solutions.

Reuven Gal

Energy Forum 50: Agricultural land dual-use for photovoltaic electricity

Gershon Grossman , Naama Shapira

Greenhouse Gas Emissions Registry in Israel - Accounting and Reporting Protocol

Ofira Ayalon , Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Tal Goldrath , Naama Shapira , Ecotraders Ltd

Survey Security Personal in the Mixed Cities 2020

Ali Nohad , Ruth Lewin-Chen , Ola Najami Yousef

Fake News and National Resilience. Report from round table discussion, July 29th, 2021

Eitan Adres , Reuven Gal , Ron Kenett , Ella Barzani

Review of the challenges to the Israeli Industry and the business sector in the next decade

Gilead Fortuna , Yuval Neev

Leadership and Academic Management in Institutions of Higher Education – Universities. Literature survey and in-depth interviews with officials

Daphne Getz , Oshrat Katz Shacham , Rinat Klein , Sima Tziperfal

Indices for Science, Technology and Innovation in Israel and international comparison. Key Figures

Daphne Getz , Tsipy Buchnik , Ilia Zatcovetsky

R&D outputs in Israel: Inventive Characteristics of Local and Foreign Activity in the Israel Patent Authority

Eran Leck , Daphne Getz , Ilia Zatcovetsky

R&D Outputs in Israel / Analysis of Scientific Publications - 2020

Daphne Getz , Rinat Klein , Ella Barzani

System Analysis of Technology Transfer Policies and Models in Higher Education

Arnon Bentur , Daphne Getz , Oshrat Katz Shacham

Separation of Organic Waste – at the Source or at a Facility?

Ofira Ayalon , Yaniv Reingewertz , Shira Daskal , Elias Bisharat , Naama Shapira

Building a personal resilience through contact with nature in the times of Corona

Ofira Ayalon , Keren Kaplan-Mintz , Tzipi Eshet , Orly Nathan , Arin Khashan , Naama Shapira

Ancillary benefit assessment of JNF forests: physical and psychological well-being, cultural services, and economic aspects

Ofira Ayalon , Keren Kaplan-Mintz , Tzipi Eshet , Orly Nathan , Arin Khashan , Ziv Shina , Edna Fichtman , Naama Shapira

Why Startups Fail: A Survey of Empirical Studies

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

The Economic Impact of the Abraham Accords After One Year: Passions vs. Interests

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

Social Resilience In Arab Society

Ali Nohad

National Strategy for Framing and Prioritizing Environmental Protection Research and Development Topics

Ofira Ayalon , Adi Wolfson , Daniel Madar , Naama Shapira , Maayan Zerbib Tsion

Indices for Science, Technology and Innovation in Israel and international comparison. Specified issues

Daphne Getz , Tsipy Buchnik , Ilia Zatcovetsky

Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting and Registration System in Israel: Summary of Reports for 2017

Ofira Ayalon , Miriam Lev-On , Perry Lev-On , Naama Shapira

Fixing military conscription by adding new mistakes? Critical comments on “Equal for All” guideline.

Asaf Malhi , Stuart Cohen , Reuven Gal

Defense R&D and Economic Growth in Israel: A Research Agenda, Science, Technology and the Economy Program STE-WP-4

Dan Peled

The Society and National Security

Nehemia Friedland , Asher Arian , Avi (Alan) Kirshenbaum , Amit Karin , Nicole Fleischer

Terrorism Risk and their impact on tourism

Sharon Regev , Benjamin Bental

Adaptation Processes and Consumer Behavior Under Uncertainty Security Conditions

Aviad Tur-Sinai

The Struggle for Palestinian Hearts and Minds: Violence and Public Opinion in the Second Intifada

David Jaeger , Klor F. Esteban , Sami H. Miaari , Daniele Paserman

An Evaluation of Strategic Arms Limitation Agreements Model, with an Application to the Israeli-Syrian Conflict

Kobi Kagan , Asher Tishler , Avi Weiss

Religious Terrorism: A Cross-Country Analysis

Naomi E. Feldman , Bradley Ruffle

Terror and the Costs of Crime

Eric D. Gould , Guy Stecklov

Are Voters Sensitive to Terrorism? Direct Evidence from the Israeli Electorate

Claude Berrebi , Klor F. Esteban

The Economic Consequences of the Use and Control of Land Resources by the Defense Sector in Israel

Zalman F. Shiffer , Oren Amiram

Allocating Security Expenditures under Knightian Uncertainty: an Info-Gap Approach

Michael Ben-Gad , Yakov Ben-Haim , Dan Peled

Investment Policies in Defense R&D Programs

Oren Setter , Asher Tishler

Space Technology, Patterns of Warfare and Force Build-up: Between a Power and a Small State

Deganit Paikowsky

Economics of National Security (ENS) - Third Anniversary Conference, Daniel Hotel, Herzelyia, 14/12/2006

The Cycle of Violence? An Empirical Analysis of Fatalities in the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict

David Jaeger , Daniele Paserman

Establishment of R&D Anti-Terror Warfare Mechanism for Homeland Security Protection from Terrorism

Orna Barri , Liron Nadav , Ilan Kuziatin , Shmulik Yachin , Manuel Trajtenberg , Danny Arditi , Hemi Peker , Dan Inbar

Violence, Crime and Policing in Arab Society: Personal and Community Security Index- 2019

Ali Nohad , Ruth Lewin-Chen

The Economic Impact of the Abraham Accords After One Year: Passions vs. Interests

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

Strategic Competition – U.S. China 2022 – An Israeli Perspective

Gilead Fortuna , Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani , Tamar Dayan

Past initiatives to strengthen the Israeli society: Lessons from the Past

Ron Kenett , Reuven Gal , Eitan Adres , Hagit Glickman , Ali Nohad , chezki Farkash

Brain-Storming about Home-Front under War Situation.

Reuven Gal , Baruch Nevo

Energy Forum 43: Breaking Israel's energy isolation

Gershon Grossman , Naama Shapira

The strategic implications of Chinese investments in Israel's economy and infrastructure

Zehev Tadmor , Uzi Arad , Dror Strum , Yadin Dudai , שאול חורב

The Contribution of Science to Israeli Security

Reuven Eshel

Law enforcement in the 21st century :Law, Government&Politics, Science&Technology

Daniel Weihs , Idit Hakimi , David Cohen , Israel Barak

Law enforcement in the 21st century: Society, Economy, Minorities, Internal Security

Israel Barak , Idit Hakimi , Daniel Weihs , David Cohen

Turning the Pyramid Upside Down

Manuel Trajtenberg , Hadar Zer Aviv , Ron Leyzer , Ehud Uziel

Ultra-Orthodox Youth: Status Assessment for 2011 and Three Possible Scenarios for 2021

Reuven Gal , Gilad Malach

Towards a reform of the tax system

Manuel Trajtenberg , Itamar Popliker

Fixing military conscription by adding new mistakes? Critical comments on “Equal for All” guideline.

Asaf Malhi , Stuart Cohen , Reuven Gal

“Common Ground”: Agreed Road Map for Long-Term National Paradigms

Eitan Adres , Reuven Gal , Zehev Tadmor , Irad Yavneh

Statistical analysis of Corona data: A Roundtable

Ron Kenett , David Steinberg , Edna Schechtman , Reuven Gal

Focused Repatriation. The Demography and the Social Processes in the Jewish Communities in the World

Ilia Zatcovetsky , Ayelet Raveh , Daphne Getz

Arab minority participation in collective action for provision of public goods in the general Israeli society.

Eitan Adres

Periphery-Academy relations: past, present and future

Carmit Padan

‘Tal’s Law’ – Background, Challenges and Optional Solutions.

Reuven Gal

Survey Security Personal in the Mixed Cities 2020

Ali Nohad , Ruth Lewin-Chen , Ola Najami Yousef

Fake News and National Resilience. Report from round table discussion, July 29th, 2021

Eitan Adres , Reuven Gal , Ron Kenett , Ella Barzani

Violence, Crime, and Policing in Arab Society in The Age of Covid

Ali Nohad , Ola Najami Yousef , Yonatan Arie

Evaluation of R&D Instruments for Fostering Academia-Industry Collaboration: The Case of the MAGNET Consortia

Eran Leck , Vered Gilad , Daphne Getz , Sima Tziperfal , Rinat Klein

Survey of Attitudes of the Residents of Umm El-Fahm

Ali Nohad

Characterizing the term ‘Benevolent community’

Ayala Keisar-Shugerman , Shay Ben-Yosef , Ron Kenett , Ayelet Raveh , Reuven Gal

Best Practices (and/or Intervention Programs) for Benevolent Community

Ayala Keisar-Shugerman , Shay Ben-Yosef , Reuven Gal , Ron Kenett , Ayelet Raveh

Indicators for Benevolent Community

Shay Ben-Yosef , Ayala Keisar-Shugerman , Ron Kenett , Reuven Gal , Ayelet Raveh

Community and Support Centers for Former Haredim – founded by Yotzim Le'Shinuy ('Out-for-Change') Association.

Ayala Keisar-Shugerman , Ron Kenett , Amir Ram , Lenna Kenett , Sima Tziperfal , Ayelet Raveh , Reuven Gal

From Geo/Bio-Politics to G2G Agreements and Public–Private Partnership: the Unique Role of the Israeli Eco-System in Ethiopia

Shelly Gottfried , Amir Sabhat , Eleonora Poli , Ayelet Raveh , Ilia Zatcovetsky , Nebiyou Yirga

"Post-Truth" Phenomena: Definitions, Consequences and Solutions

Shakked Dabran-Zivan , Ayelet Baram-Tsabari

Engineering, Society and Environment

Baruch Karp , Avigdor Zonnenshain , Arnon Bentur

Populism - A Survey of Recent Research

Shlomo Maital

Science & Technology Education in Israel: Selected Indicators for the Development of a Risk Management Strategy regarding Possible Future Shortages of S&T Teachers in Upper-Secondary Schools

Orit Hazzan , Tsipy Buchnik , Orly Nathan , Ayelet Raveh

Orthodox Employment - Information Booklet Second Edition

Ilia Zatcovetsky , Reuven Gal

Between (MACHA”R) Tomorrow and Today: Academic System for Haredim at a Cross-Road

Ilia Zatcovetsky , Reuven Gal

Ultra-Orthodox (‘Haredi’) Jews in Israel’s Society: A 2014 Status Report.

Reuven Gal

Changes in productivity amongst Jewish women

Ilia Zatcovetsky

MACHA'R IS ALREADY HERE

Ilia Zatcovetsky

Orthodox Employment - Information Booklet

Reuven Gal , Ilia Zatcovetsky

The Way to Integration

Ilia Zatcovetsky , Reuven Gal

"Road Map" - A National Program to Promote the Integration of the Ultra-Orthodox Population in the Israeli Economy

Reuven Gal , Ilia Zatcovetsky

A comparative study on the scientific and technological research in Israel and some middle eastern countries, using quantitative indicators, second ed

Yair Even-Zohar , Daphne Getz , Uri Kirsch

A comparative study on the scientific and technological research in Israel and some middle eastern countries, using quantitative indicators

Yair Even-Zohar , Daphne Getz , Uri Kirsch

Holistic Assessment of Science Communication Based on the Positions of Different Stakeholders: Scientists, Teachers, Undergraduates, High School Students, and the Public

Yehudit Dori , Zehavit Kohen , Orit Herscovitz

Do High-Skill Immigrants Raise Productivity? Evidence from Israeli Manufacturing Firms, 1990-1999 STE-WP-36

Daniele Paserman

Gender Issues in Computer Science and Software Engineering

Orit Hazzan , Dalit Levi , Tami Lapidot

The Society and National Security

Nehemia Friedland , Asher Arian , Avi (Alan) Kirshenbaum , Amit Karin , Nicole Fleischer

The Struggle for Palestinian Hearts and Minds: Violence and Public Opinion in the Second Intifada

David Jaeger , Klor F. Esteban , Sami H. Miaari , Daniele Paserman

Terror and the Costs of Crime

Eric D. Gould , Guy Stecklov

Are Voters Sensitive to Terrorism? Direct Evidence from the Israeli Electorate

Claude Berrebi , Klor F. Esteban

Preliminary Reflections on Knotty Issues, University Education and Human Resources

Sheldon Rothblatt

The Triad Research University Model or a Post 20th Century Research University Model, University Education and Human Resources

Zehev Tadmor

The Golden Age of Scientific Technological Research University

Zehev Tadmor

On Mass Higher Education and Institutional Diversity, University Education and Human Resources

Martin Trow

Equity and Efficiency Effects of Different Funding Arrangements for Higher Education: A Calibrated Analysis Applied to Israel

Yaakov Gilboa , Moshe Justman

Tertiary Education in Israel A New Paradigm for Policy Making

Ami Volanski , Nissan Limor

The Jewish People Today: Between Necessity and Freedom

Aviezer Ravitzky

Comments on National Governance

Shlomo Avineri

The Necessity of Strategic Thinking: A Constitutive Vision for Israel and its Implications

Ruth Gavizon

Modern Jewish Identities and the State of Israel

Moshe Halbertal

A secular, liberal, modern vision of Israel

Zehev Tadmor

Human Resources for Science and Technology in Israel - Selected Topics (Part B)

Daphne Getz , Tsipy Buchnik , Bella Zalmanovich

Human Resources for Science and Technology in Israel - Selected Topics (Part A)

Daphne Getz , Tsipy Buchnik , Bella Zalmanovich

Tuition Fees in Higher Education in Israel

Gury Zilkha

The Israeli innovation system: An overview of national policy and cultural aspects

Daphne Getz , Vered Gilad

The Neaman Document -A study on Israeli Public Diplomacy; A Joint Project of the S. Neaman Institute, Technion And the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Israel.

Dov Shinar , Roei Davidson , Dalia Liran-Alper , Lea Mandelzis , Arye Naor , Anat First , Naama Maoz , Haim Hagay , Sagit Yakubovich , Moshe Elad , Meir Shlomo