The Global Environmental Market - An Economic Opportunity for Israel. First Position Paper, Analysis and Initial Conclusions

Yitzhak Goren, Prof. Ofira Ayalon, Eli Israeli, Z. Berl, Prof. Yoram Avnimelech, Mr. Yaron Arnon, Noam Gressel, Prof. Mordechai Shechter

Cite As:
Goren Yitzhak, Ayalon Ofira, Israeli Eli, Berl Z., Avnimelech Yoram, Arnon Yaron, Gressel Noam, Shechter Mordechai. The Global Environmental Market - An Economic Opportunity for Israel. First Position Paper, Analysis and Initial Conclusions Haifa Israel: Samuel Neaman Institute, 2003. https://neaman.org.il/EN/Global-Environmental-Market-Economic-Opportunity-for-Israel-First-Position-Paper-Analysis-Initial-Conclusions

Download files:

The Global Environmental Market - An Economic Opportunity for Israel. First Position Paper, Analysis and Initial Conclusions(426KB)

For decades, Israel has led the world in finding new methods of water conservation. More recently, its scientists have also developed pioneering methods of environmental monitoring, protection & remediation, recycling and waste treatment as well as alternative energy. Israeli firms in this field are increasingly active in the emerging markets of developing countries. Israel is especially strong in providing such services, and many Israeli firms and consultants work with organizations as the World Bank, WHO and FAO as environmental experts. In Israel, close cooperation between university R&D and industry assures rapid commercial application of solutions to environmental problems, yet investments in environmental R&D are rather low in comparison with other developing countries (O.1%, from total R&D budget, in Israel, 3.2% in Canada, 4.2% in Denmark). The market of global environmental technologies in 1994 surpassed $100 million, increased to $250 million by 1997 and expected to increase to over $600 million by 2004.
A proper policy could significantly increase the share of these technologies in export from Israel.

Business opportunities of environmental technologies lie in two main streams, in both Israeli technology can and should be involved: low-tech, rather inexpensive and labor intensive technologies exported to developing countries, high-tech and sophisticated technologies to be used and exported to developing countries.

This policy paper describes the markets, business opportunities as well as difficulties, needs and means to achieve a goal of exporting 1% of the global market of environmental technologies and services from Israel.

Publications that might interest you

Grand Strategy For Israel

Uzi Arad , Dror Strum , Zehev Tadmor

Undoing the “Gordian Knot”: a transportation roadmap for the short run

Manuel Trajtenberg , Shuki Cohen , Alon Pardo , Nir Sharav

Towards a reform of the tax system

Manuel Trajtenberg , Itamar Popliker

The Corona Crisis as a Growth Engine for the North of Israel

Osnat Akirav , Gilead Fortuna , Avigdor Zonnenshain

Arab minority participation in collective action for provision of public goods in the general Israeli society.

Eitan Adres

Review of the challenges to the Israeli Industry and the business sector in the next decade

Gilead Fortuna , Yuval Neev

The Global Economic Impact of the Russia-Ukraine War

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

From Geo/Bio-Politics to G2G Agreements and Public–Private Partnership: the Unique Role of the Israeli Eco-System in Ethiopia

Shelly Gottfried , Amir Sabhat , Eleonora Poli , Ayelet Raveh , Ilia Zatcovetsky , Nebiyou Yirga

Orthodox Employment - Information Booklet Second Edition

Ilia Zatcovetsky , Reuven Gal

Orthodox Employment - Information Booklet

Reuven Gal , Ilia Zatcovetsky

The Way to Integration

Ilia Zatcovetsky , Reuven Gal

"Road Map" - A National Program to Promote the Integration of the Ultra-Orthodox Population in the Israeli Economy

Reuven Gal , Ilia Zatcovetsky

Tax Benefits for R&D in Israel

Dan Peled , Benjamin Bental , Avi Sasi , Ilia Zatcovetsky

Integration of electric and hybrid vehicles in Israel's transportation system – Phase B: economic analysis and life cycle assessment

Ofira Ayalon , Idan Liebes , Gadi Rosental , Dana Gabay

Integration of electric and hybrid vehicles in Israel's transportation system – Phase A: literature review

Ofira Ayalon , Yaara Grinberg , Idan Liebes , Gadi Rosental , Dana Gabay

Evolutionary Interpretation of VC Policy in Israel, Germany, UK and Scotland (STE-WP-45)

Gil Avnimelech , Alessandro Rosiello , Morris Teubal

VC Policy: Moving from a Financial Perspective towards a Systemic and Evolutionary Framework (STE-WP-42)

Gil Avnimelech , Alessandro Rosiello , Morris Teubal

Do High-Skill Immigrants Raise Productivity? Evidence from Israeli Manufacturing Firms, 1990-1999 STE-WP-36

Daniele Paserman

Harnessing Success: Determinants of University Technology Licensing Performance STE-WP-35

Sharon Belenzon , Mark Shnkerman

KNOWLEDGE-INTENSIVE PROPERTY RIGHTS (STE-WP-39)

Cristiano Antonelli , Morris Teubal

The Limits of Capital: Transcending the Public Financer - Private Producer Split in R&D (STE-WP-40)

Dan Breznitz , Amos Zehavi

Innovation Policy for Development: an Overview STE-WP-34

Manuel Trajtenberg

Microeconomic Insights from Israel's Venture Capital Emergence: Towards a Theory of Evolutionary Targeting of Infant Industries STE-33-2006

Gil Avnimelech , Morris Teubal

The Dye Famine and its Aftermath: Knowledge Diffusion and Entry STE-WP-32

David Genesove

Venture Capitalists, Public Offerings or Strategic Investors? Financial Liquidation Profiles of Israeli Hi-Tech Firms STE-WP-31

Niron Hashai , Jonathan Menuhin

What Affects Technion Faculty Members' Decision to Found a Start-Up Firm? Effects of the Business Opportunity and the Entrepreneur's (faculty)

Avi Fiegenbaum , Shane Scott , Miriam Erez , Oshrat Kremer-Srabstein , Moshe Givon

From Ivory Tower to Industrial Promotion:The Case of Yale University and the Biotechnology Cluster in New Haven, Connecticut, STE-WP-28

Shiri Breznitz

Start-up funding inefficiencies due to VC's Limited horizon, STE-WP-29

Eugene Kandel , D. Leshchinskii , Harry Yuklea

Evolutionary Innovation and High Tech Policy: What can we Learn from Israel's Targeting of Venture Capital STE-WP-25

Gil Avnimelech , Morris Teubal

Public vs. Private Technological Incubator Programs: Privatizing the Technological Incubators in Israel STE-WP-26

Amnon Frenkel , Daniel Shefer , Michal Miller

Monopolies in Competition:The Balance between Innovativeness and Competition in the Israeli Competition Law STE-WP-27

Michal S. Gal

Firm Growth Profiles (FGPs): Towards an Action-Based View of Firm Development STE-WP-24

Jonathan Menuhin , Niron Hashai

Can Venture Capital Funds Pick Winners? Evidence from Pre-IPO Survival Rates and Post-IPO Performance STE-WP-23

Yishay Yafeh , Hedva Bar

Immigrants in the Hi-Tech Sector: Comparison to Natives and the Effect of Training STE-WP-22-2004

Sarit Cohen Goldner , Zvi Eckstein

Innovation and the Limits of State's Power: R&D and Industrial Policy in taiwan in IC Design and Software STE-WP-21-2004

Dan Breznitz

Evolutionary Venture Capital Policies: Insights from a Product life Cycle Analysis of Israel's Venture Capital Industry, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-20-2003

Gil Avnimelech , Morris Teubal

A Micro-Economic Approach to Government Support of R&D Investments in the Private Sector, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Workin

Dan Galai , Zvi Wiener

The Impact of R&D Spillover on Growth and Productivity in Israeli Manufacturing Industries 1990-1994, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-14

Simcha Bar-Eliezer , Arie Bregman

Universal Banking and Investment in R&D Intensive Companies an Empirical Analysis STE-WP-15 , 2002

Aharon Shaket

Incentives and Invention in Universities, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-18-2003

Saul Lach , Mark Schankerman

Financing R&D in Mature Companies: An Empirical Analysis, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-10

Asher Blass , Oved Yosha

Is Venture Capital Special? Empirical Evidence from a Government Initiated Venture Capital Market, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-9

Hedva Bar

Conceiving New Industrial Systems: The Different Emergence Paths of the High-Technology Industry in Israel and Ireland, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-11

Dan Breznitz

The Military as a Public Space - The Role of the IDF in the Israeli Software Innovation System, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-13

Dan Breznitz

Quantitative Growth Effects of Subsidies in a Search Theoretic R&D Modal, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-16-2002

Benjamin Bental , Dan Peled

The Determination of Success of R&D Projects: Evidence from American-Israeli Research Alliances, Science, Technology and the Economy Program STE-WP-8-2001

Oded Bizan

Cooperation and Competition in R&D with Uncertainty & Spillovers, Science, Technology and the Economy Program STE-WP-6

D. B. Silipo , Avi Weiss

Defense R&D and Economic Growth in Israel: A Research Agenda, Science, Technology and the Economy Program STE-WP-4

Dan Peled

R&D, Subsidies and Productivity, Science, Technology and the Economy Program STE-WP-7

Saul Lach , Robert M. Sauer

Sources of U.S. Longevity Increase, 1960-1997, Science, Technology and the Economy Program STE-WP-3

Frank Lichtenberg

R&D Policy in Israel: An Overview and Reassessment, Science, Technology and the Economy Program STE-WP-2

Manuel Trajtenberg

Do R&D Subsidies Stimulate or Displace Private R&D? Evidence from Israel, Science, Technology and the Economy Program (STE) - Working Papers Series STE-WP-1

Saul Lach

The global Environmental Market - An Economic Opportunity for Israel Primary model to assess the costs and benefits of governmental investment in the field of environmental technologies

Yitzhak Goren , Ofira Ayalon , Doron Lavi , Mark Sczabshvitz

Proceedings of conference- Business opportunities in Environmental Technologies

Ofira Ayalon

Conservation of the rural landscape: Implementation model of sustainable agriculture in selected agricultural areas in Israel

Liron Amdur , Haim Zaban , Yoram Avnimelech , Ofira Ayalon

Sustainable Agriculture. How may the external values of agriculture be integrated as part of the farmer's income, in the different areas of Israel

Haim Zaban , Noa Feller , Liron Amdur , Yoram Avnimelech , Ofira Ayalon

Terrorism Risk and their impact on tourism

Sharon Regev , Benjamin Bental

Is Job Stability at the Beginning of One's Career Good for Job Stability Later On?

Aviad Tur-Sinai , Dmitri Romanov

Adaptation Processes and Consumer Behavior Under Uncertainty Security Conditions

Aviad Tur-Sinai

An Evaluation of Strategic Arms Limitation Agreements Model, with an Application to the Israeli-Syrian Conflict

Kobi Kagan , Asher Tishler , Avi Weiss

Economics of National Security (ENS) - Third Anniversary Conference, Daniel Hotel, Herzelyia, 14/12/2006

Investments in Higher Education and Economic Performance: Israel in an international perspective

Amnon Frenkel , Eran Leck

Higher education policy in Israel - accessibility, quality and excellence with limited resources

Uri Kirsch

Privatization in Higher Education

Gury Zilkha

Economic assessment of current deposit law and suggested packaging law in Israel

Ofira Ayalon , Mordechai Shechter , Gadi Rosental , Machum Yehoshua , Yael Atar Peled

Implications of expanding the Deposit Law to 1.5 liter bottles

Ofira Ayalon , Gadi Rosental , Machum Yehoshua , Mordechai Shechter

Data and Indicators on Aerospace Engineering, ICT and Biotechnology in Israel

Daphne Getz , Vered Gilad , Marian Shumaf - Tehawkho

Funding of Higher Education

Meir Zadok

Israel 2028 - Vision and Strategy for Economy and Society in a Global World

Eliyahu Hurvitz , David Brodet

A Strategy for Developing Employment Opportunities for the Arabs in Israel: The Vision for Expanding the Arab Middle Class

Yusof Jabareen

Evaluation of the Space Industry's Impact on the Israeli Economy

Daphne Getz , Arkady Katsman , Bella Zalmanovich , Deganit Paikowsky , Vered Gilad , Yair Even-Zohar

National Energy Technologies Research and Development Survey

Ofira Ayalon , Michal Nachmany , Tal Goldrath , Daphne Getz , Vered Gilad , Eran Leck , Yifaat Baron

Policy recommendations for treatment of packaging waste in Israel

Ofira Ayalon , Gadi Rosental , Michal Nachmany , Tal Goldrath , Idan Dorfman , Michal Grossman , Mordechai Shechter

Technion's Contribution to the Israeli Economy through its Graduates

Amnon Frenkel , Shlomo Maital

TOD - Transit Oriented Development Urban Planning around Accessible Rail Transit

Dan Gat , Yehuda Hayuth , Peter katz , Shlomo Maital , Yodan Rofe

Innovation of Foreign R&D Centres in Israel: Evidence from Patent and Firm Level Data

Daphne Getz , Eran Leck , Vered Gilad

Evaluation of the Space Industry's Impact on the Israeli Economy

Daphne Getz , Arkady Katsman , Bella Zalmanovich , Deganit Paikowsky , Vered Gilad , Yair Even-Zohar

Upgrading the economic systems of Israels north

Avigdor Zonnenshain , Gilead Fortuna , Tamar Dayan

Reforming Parental Leave: doing good to newborns, their parents and the economy

Manuel Trajtenberg , Ron Leyzer

Why Startups Fail: A Survey of Empirical Studies

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

The Economic Impact of the Abraham Accords After One Year: Passions vs. Interests

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

Benford’s Law: A survey of its varied applications

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

Corporate responsibility of industrial sectors with enhanced environmental impact in Israel – From corporate responsibility to impact valuation

Levi Gottlieb

Assessing the economic ramifications resulting from climate warming in the city of Tel Aviv-Yafo

Naama Shapira , Orly Nathan , Dana Gabay , Ofira Ayalon

Past initiatives to strengthen the Israeli society: Lessons from the Past

Ron Kenett , Reuven Gal , Eitan Adres , Hagit Glickman , Ali Nohad , chezki Farkash

Israel in 2030, Liberal Democracy, Populistic or Autocracy? ‘Round Table’ Discussion

Eitan Adres , Reuven Gal , Eli Salzberger , Shlomo Maital , Ido Erev , Oshrat Katz Shacham

Estimation of “Intel Israel” contribution to the National Economy

Gilead Fortuna , Yuval Neev , Daniel Friman , Avigdor Zonnenshain , Michael Werner , Rafi Nave , Tamar Dayan

We will bounce back

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

Electric Vehicles Charging Infrastructure in Israel: Implementation Policy and Technical Guidelines

Idan Liebes , Ofira Ayalon , Roland Steinmetz , Roos van der Ploeg , Peter Hogeveen

Assessment of the economic damage of the fuel leak at the junction Be'er Ora 12.03.14 - Economic opinion

Ofira Ayalon , Tzipi Eshet

National Environmental Priorities, Position Paper X: Innovative agricultural technology industry in Israel, 2016

Ofira Ayalon , Shiri Freund-Koren , Idan Liebes , Maayan Zerbib Tsion

Characterization and master plan for the Shefar’am new industrial park

Eitan Adres , Gilead Fortuna , Avigdor Zonnenshain

Integration of electric and hybrid vehicles in Israel's transportation system

Ofira Ayalon , Yaara Grinberg , Idan Liebes , Gadi Rosental , Dana Gabay

Science and Technology Indicators in Israel: An International Comparison

Daphne Getz , Mansour Hani , Dan Peled , Marian Shumaf - Tehawkho

The Global Economic Impact of COVID-19:A Summary of Research

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

Oil Shale Occurrences in Israel - Geological Updated information

Tsevi Minster

Israel Economy and the Corona Crisis – Summary of a round table discussion and major conclusion

Gilead Fortuna , Giora Shalgi , Avigdor Zonnenshain , Eitan Adres , Yuval Neev , Ron Kenett , Rafi Nave , Tamar Dayan

Sustainable Energy Market in Israel

Dan Zaslavsky

Characterizing master plan for the industrial park Mishor Rotem

Eitan Adres , Gilead Fortuna , Avigdor Zonnenshain , Yuval Neev , Daniel Porat , Rafi Nave , Tamar Dayan

Crossing the Valley of Death Between Academic Research and Effective Policy

Shlomo Maital

Gross Domestic Problem: Why GDP Misleads & How to Fix It

Shlomo Maital , Ella Barzani

To unravel the "Gordian Knot" 2.0: Tackling congestion via road pricing and shared rides

Manuel Trajtenberg , Hadar Zer Aviv

Towards a New Fiscal Policy for Israel: Balancing Budgetary Responsibility and Societal Needs

Manuel Trajtenberg , Itamar Popliker

Towards a New Fiscal Policy for Israel: Balancing Budgetary Responsibility and Societal Needs

Manuel Trajtenberg , Itamar Popliker

Save lives, save jobs

Shlomo Maital

Proceedings of conference- Business opportunities in Environmental Technologies

Ofira Ayalon

The Current Energy Situation in Israel as a Departure Point for Future Planning

Amnon Enav

BUSINESS RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT 2000-2001

Central Bureau of Statistics

High tech nation and market driven economy

Zehev Tadmor

The Global Environmental Market - An Economic Opportunity for Israel. First Position Paper, Analysis and Initial Conclusions

Yitzhak Goren , Ofira Ayalon , Eli Israeli , Z. Berl , Yoram Avnimelech , Yaron Arnon , Noam Gressel , Mordechai Shechter

Analysis and Policy Recommendations for Technology Transfer from Universities to Industry. Final Report

Daniel Shefer , Amnon Frenkel

Total Factor Productivity as a Performance Benchmark for Firms: Theory and Evidence, SNI R&D Policy Papers Series

Hariolf Grupp , Shlomo Maital

Community network, information Technology, community needs, technical preparedness, Kiryat- Tivon.

Evaluation of a Plan to Establish a Wind Farm in the Mediterranean Sea. Final Research Report

Eli Ben-Dov , Nitay Drimer , David Cohen , Ilan Seter , Aviv Rosen

1999 Survey of RD in the Business Sector

Central Bureau of Statistics

The Health System at a Roadcross

Manuel Trajtenberg

NATIONAL EXPENDITURE ON CIVILIAN RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT

Central Bureau of Statistics

Targeting Industries for Regional Development in Israel and in Germany – A Comparative Study, SNI R&D Policy Papers Series

Daniel Shefer , Amnon Frenkel , Knut Koschatzky , Walter H. Guenter

A Scientific-Technological Forecast - Approaching the 21st Century. Stage 2, Final Report

David Cohen , Ilana Shalev

Investments in Civilian Research & Development in Israel: Background Data for Development of a National Policy

Arnon Bentur

R&D, Firm Size and Innovation: An Empirical Analysis, SNI R&D Policy Papers Series

Daniel Shefer , Amnon Frenkel

Towards An Infrastructure Policy Consensus and A National Capital Outlay Budjet 2000-2010 (Background Paper 1)

Daniel Czamanski , Maria Marinov

University Technology Transfer in Israel: Evaluation of Projects and Determinants of Success - SNI R&D Policy Papers Series

Ofer Meseri , Shlomo Maital

Managing New Product Development and Innovation A Microeconomics Toolbox

Hariolf Grupp , Shlomo Maital

1998-1989 NATIONAL EXPENDITURE ON CIVILIAN RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT

Central Bureau of Statistics

The Contribution of Science to Israeli Security

Reuven Eshel

The Contribution of Science to Civilian Industry in Israel

Reuven Eshel

An Examination of the Economic Implications for Israel of Space Exploration

Joshef Shapira , Avi Rave , Balila Dekel

Economic Incentives in Solid Urban Waste Policy. Final Report

Mordechai Shechter , Yoram Avnimelech , Ofira Ayalon

Technometric Benchmarking: Towards an Interactive Operational Model for Management of Technology and Innovation in Science-Based Startups, Selected Re

Shlomo Maital , Hariolf Grupp

An Examination of the Economic Implications for Israel of Space Exploration. Executive Summary

Joshef Shapira , Avi Rave , Balila Dekel

Report on the Israeli Information Technology (IT) Market

David Cohen , M. Phil

The Middle East Oil Decade and Beyond

Gad Gilbar

The Chemical Industry 2000 Potential for Future Growth

Ephraim Kehat , Reuven Wachs

Evaluation of the Impact of Traffic Overload and Parking Fees on the Demand for Travel - A Study on an Event at the Technion

Gila Albert , David Mahalel

Conference on shore extensions and artifical islands off the coast of Israel

Gdalia Shelf , Yoram Zimmels

The Role of the Institute for Ceramics and Silicates

Haim Kostiner , Amnon Frenkel

Human Resources Policy in an Age of Change, 1994, (Internal Report)

Daniel Shimsoni

An Evaluation of the Promotion of Immigrant Entrepreneurship in the Haifa Area

N. Gomelski , D. Simmons-Cohen

Entrepreneurial Theory and Practice: Immigrant Opportunities

N. Gomelski , D. Simmons-Cohen , D. Kzamanski

The Chemical Industry 2000, Phase B

Ephraim Kehat , Reuven Wachs

Social and Economic Implications of Employee Cutbacks

Bilha Mannheim , David Cohen

Quality and Productivity in Research & Development

E. Darel , Zeev Bonen

The Chemical Industry 2000, Phase A

Reuven Wachs , Ephraim Kehat

Increasing Productivity in Research & Development: Conclusions of a Seminar

E. Darel , Zeev Bonen

Migration To and From Development Towns in Israel

Tobi Alfandari , Daniel Shefer

Proceedings of the Second International Workshop on Civilian Space Applications

Daniel Weihs

Measurement of Performance parameters for the Israeli Industry

A. Segal , Gilead Fortuna , Reuel Shenar

The Aeronautic Infrastructure in Arab Countries

Aviv Rosen , Joshef Rom

Use of Alternative Energy Sources in Light of the Persian Gulf Crisis

Alexander Burcat

Increasing Productivity in R&D

E. Darel , Zeev Bonen

The Diagnostics Industry in Israel, Evaluating the Technological Level Using the Technometric System

Amnon Frenkel , Shlomo Maital

An Examination of the Wage System of Technion Professors - Current Problems and Solutions

Abraham Friedman

The Plastics Industry in Israel - Current Economic Status and Future Alternate Economic Outlook

David Frenkel , Shmuel Kenig

Absorption of Soviet Immigrants at the Technion

David Cohen

The Plastics Industry in Israel - Status Report

Z. Berl

Principles and Systems for Planning of Human Resources in Research and Technology in the OECD Countries, and Lessons for Israel

David Cohen , A. Shaliv , B. Toren

Applications and Development Trends in Plastics for Packaging, Agriculture and Construction

Joshef Miltz , Nehama Pazi , Moshe Goren , Moshe Puterman

Agroplastics - A Market Analysis

Menaem Gotliv

Polymers and Plastics in Israel - Final Report

Shmuel Kenig , David Cohen

The Electronics Industry in the World and in Israel - Economic Directions and Future Trends

Uri Shimoni

The European Common Market in 1992: Positions and Perspectives on the Plastics and Polymer Industry

Shlomo Maital

Plastic Materials: Markets and Technology by Global Region

Ramon Joshef Albalak , Shmuel Kenig

The Polymer Industry in Israel and the World: Present Status and Future Prospective

David Frenkel

A Retrospective View of Israel's 'Project Renewal' - Lessons for Planning for New Immigrants in the 1990's

Rachelle Alterman

Innovation at the Crossroads between Science and Technology

M. Kranzberg , Y. Elkana , Zehev Tadmor

Civilian Space Applications, Proceedings of the Workshop - Technion

Daniel Weihs , David Cohen

Report #2– Israel Adaptation to Climate Change Policy Recommendations

Mordechai Shechter , Haim Kutiel , Nurit Kliot , Manfred Green , Marcelo Sterenberg , Isaac Guedi Capeluto , Arnon Sofer , Ofira Ayalon , Debby Kaufman